You’re Not Good Enough Book Tag: Harry Potter Edition

I was tagged by bookgraphyKay Wisteria, and Perfectly Tolerable to do this tag. Thanks to all of you! I’m glad I’ve established myself as the resident Harry Potter nerd! 😂

The You’re Not Good Enough Tag was created  by  ReadLikeWildfire and   Beccathebookreviewer, and turned Potterish by Live Love Read.


  • Write 30 character names on pieces of paper.
  • Put them in a jar/mug/cup.
  • Randomly choose two pieces of paper for every question. In each of the 15 questions, you have to decide which of the two characters fits the question and which one is not good enough.


1. You only have one more spot on your Spelling Bee team. Who do you pick to complete your team?

Lupin or Arthur Weasley

Sorry Arthur, but I’m always going to choose Lupin. Plus, he was a prefect and a professor, so I’m sure he’s good at spelling.

Image result for remus lupin gif

2. Both characters want to kill you. Which one would you kill first so you have a better chance of surviving?

Lily Potter or Hagrid

I feel awful! But let’s be real, Lily would probably be better at killing people than Hagrid, so I’d have a better chance of surviving if I did this! Although I don’t know of any scenario where that would happen…

Related image

3. You’re on the bachelor/bachelorette and you’re down to these two characters. Which one are you going to give your rose to?

Draco Malfoy or Cedric Diggory

I mean, there’s a reason everyone in Hogwarts was in love with Cedric.

Image result for cedric diggory gif

4. You’ve been chosen for the Hunger Games. Who would most likely volunteer in your place?

Dobby or Fleur Delacour

I would be so sad that he would volunteer, but he definitely would. He’s just that kind of person….er, elf. And Fleur would not volunteer unless I was her sister.

Image result for dobby gif

5. You’re stranded on an island with an active volcano. Which character would you throw into a volcano as a sacrifice?

Uncle Vernon or Molly Weasley


Image result for uncle vernon gif

(^ me sacrificing Vernon into a volcano in Molly’s place.)

6. You’re the next DC/Marvel superhero (with your own T.V. show, of course). Who is your sidekick?

Fred & George or Snape

FRED & GEORGE (yes I put them as one person) WOULD BE THE BEST SUPERHERO SIDEKICKS. Now I really want this as a TV show.

Image result for fred and george gif

7. You’re a manager of an avocado-admiring company. Who would you fire for lack of communication skills?

Dumbledore or Luna Lovegood

Let’s be real, Dumbledore spent years keeping secrets from his students and employees, so he’s not the best at communication. And there’s no world that I’ll ever willingly fire Luna Lovegood.

Image result for dumbledore gif

8. You’ve just finished a book in which your favorite character dies. Which character is most likely to comfort you?

Ron Weasley or Dean Thomas

Even though he has the emotional range of a teaspoon, I’d want Ron comforting me after an emotional character death. At least he’d be good at making me laugh.

Image result for ron weasley gif

9. Ugh, it’s high school. Who would most likely be part of the popular clique?

Sirius Black or Voldemort

HAH he already was! Voldemort (or Tom Riddle, if you will) got nothing on Sirius Black.

Image result for sirius black gif

10. The day has arrived – you’re finally a year older! Who would have the nerve to forget your birthday?

Hermione Granger or Harry Potter

Let’s be real, as much as I love Harry, I know that Hermione would NEVER forget a birthday. I’d be a little offended (esp since I celebrate Harry’s birthday every year), but I’d get over it. Just say you’re the Chosen One, Harry, and everyone will forgive you.

Image result for but i am the chosen one

11. You’ve just found an upcoming booktube star! Who would it most likely be?

Percy Weasley or Seamus Finnegan

Though Percy would probably be the most boring booktuber out there, droning on and on about the latest book on cauldron bottoms, I can definitely see him doing that.

Image result for percy weasley gif

12. Sleepover time! Unfortunately, you can only invite one person. Who would you invite?

Bellatrix Lestrange or McGonagall

NO QUESTION. I don’t want Bellatrix getting anywhere near me while I’m sleeping.

Image result for mcgonagall gif

13. Bam, you’re pregnant. Who is the father/mother?

Peter Pettigrew or Neville Longbottom

Do I even need to say it???

Image result for neville longbottom gif

14. You’ve just written a super important text. Who would see it, but not reply?

Dudley Dursley or James Potter

Dudley probably forgot how to use a phone.

Image result for dudley dursley gif

15. You’ve just woken up and it’s time for breakfast. Your mum’s been replaced by… who?!

Ginny Weasley or Buckbeak


Related image


Thanks again to the three of you who tagged me! This was so much fun!

I tag: bookwormbookclubblog | Keeping Reading Forward | whitreadslit | bookstormgirl | Winged Cynic | darklywhimsicalreader | and any other Potterheads out there!

x Margaret

17 thoughts on “You’re Not Good Enough Book Tag: Harry Potter Edition

  1. I can’t believe you were tagged three times for this 😂😂 Thats what you get for hosting the HP event! ❤

    I could totally see Dumbledore and Luna working at an Avocado admiring company 😂 But I would keep Luna too!

    Great answers!!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Luckily for your birthday, Hermione would remind Harry. haha.

    Thanks for tagging me, This is going to be oddles and noodles of fun! I’ll probably post my answers Thursday.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Haha Fred and George would make awesome sidekicks, and Percy as a Youtube star? I can totally see it. 😉 Now I personally would fire Luna over Dumbledore since most people don’t seem to understand her language, but I wouldn’t want to since she’s such a sweetheart.

    Terrific answers! I like your reasoning for all of these. Thanks so much for tagging me; it sounds uber fun to do!! 😊

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.